This is essentially a google doc dump, some essays I wrote a few years ago during Business and Professional Ethics. Feels like their topics are more relevant than ever, so it’s a good opportunity to publish.
TLDR; you’ll be reading about social biases and their place in business. Impressions, groupthink, recency bias, you name it. Think about how often you interact with customers, clients, partners—now think about how many first impressions you’ve made. How many you’ve assessed for yourself and how accurate they’ve actually been.
I hope you use what information and research I provide in these three essays to remind yourself of your own biases. Awareness checks are experience points. You only stand to learn, and that’s progress.
1. The Primacy Effect and First-Impression Bias
As baristas, we interact with hundreds of customers on a daily basis. Within half an hour we often introduce ourselves up to ten, twenty, or thirty times over to a plethora of personalities. Speaking from a strictly anecdotal perspective (although I’d like to believe most baristas would agree), we have and make first impressions on an almost mechanical level. Although we’d like to believe we do not give in to those initial judgements, considering they’re made with such limited information, they still influence our decision-making for unknowingly long periods of time; this is referred to as the “Primacy Effect” (Fabert, 2023, p. 13). These seemingly short-term impressions, or “thin slices”, leave stronger impacts on our psyches unbeknownst to us—unfortunately, such strength can breed an ignorant confidence in those beliefs regardless of any existing contradictions. This seemingly irrational persistence, or “belief perseverance”, can even intensify when met with opposition. As such, maintaining awareness of this bias is vital to having a better impression, or, at the very least, a more accurate one.
Over a century ago, a young German psychologist by the name of Hermann Ebbinghaus would conduct experiments on memory that would broaden testing possibilities tenfold. In 1885 he published a monograph titled Über das Gedächtnis, or translated to English, Memory. A Contribution to Experimental Psychology (Wozniak, 1999). This work presented the field of psychology a way to efficiently quantify higher mental processes, and revolutionized how psychologists would research learning and memory moving forward. What does this have to do with biases?
Through a series of experiments regarding the memory of syllables, consonants, and nonsense words, Ebbinghaus would standardize his testing and recording methodology over time and trial. With this, his results were extraordinary: he had inadvertently created the first display of the learning curve, and discovered an advantage in learning concepts over time compared to learning en masse, due to his recording of mental fatigue. Lastly, he coined both the primacy and the recency effects; the first and last details in a list maintain a higher retention rate than those in the middle (Wozniak). As such, first and last impressions might considerably be the longest lasting.
To bring this to the modern era—a study was conducted for the Journal of Business Ethics in 2021 attempting to display the relationship between a customer’s impressions on a corporation based on that corporation’s reputation. In this experiment, researchers presented consumers with both corporate social responsibility (CSR) and corporate social irresponsibility (CSI) factors at opposite times. A test group would be presented with CSR at the beginning of the week, then CSI at the end, followed by a test group that would proceed with the opposite procedure. Results showed consumer-firm relationships to strengthen when exposed to recent positive CSR, regardless of negative CSI the week prior. However, when subjects were presented with reputable corporations that were then followed by negative CSI, they still responded favorably, displaying favorability towards initial impressions or reputations compared to observed recency bias (Peasley et al., 2020).
So, we must consider how much significance first impressions hold in our subconscious—in regards to serving coffee, how customers interact with baristas based on these biases, and vice versa. However, reputation might precede them in priority on a case-by-case basis, if not at least share their value regarding perception. And, in full circle, those reputations are at least partially maintained and affected by those same first impressions. Awareness is key.
Works Cited:
Fabert, N. (2020, August 20). PSY 350: Lecture Two (Lecture). ASU.
Wozniak, R. H. (1999). Introduction to Hermann Ebbinghaus. Classics in the History of Psychology.
Retrieved August 28, 2023, from http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Ebbinghaus/wozniak.htm
Peasley, M. C., Woodroof, P. J., & Coleman, J. T. (2020). Processing Contradictory CSR
Information: The Infuence of Primacy and Recency Efects on the Consumer‑Firm Relationship.
Journal of Business Ethics, (172), 275-289. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-020-04514-4
2. Groupthink Conformity in American (Corporate) Politics
The political landscape of America has slowly but surely become an intensely polarized mess of what it once used to be. While many factors have influenced political attitudes over the past few decades, the key social psychological variables driving these shifts are clear. Voters across the nation are all affected by social pressures within their communities—their need for acceptance, their need to maintain beliefs regardless of consequential information, the manipulation of their beliefs by influential powers outside their control, all of it. Respectively, we can better take a look at these issues by defining them—social conformity, cognitive dissonance, and groupthink. They, amongst other psychological factors, have molded the minds of the American public to such a degree of disarray that most political conversations run amok with controversy, conflict, and unnecessary tension.
Social conformity occurs when people alter their behavior due to real or perceived peer pressure. Voters align with others through two main paths: seeking accurate information or desiring social acceptance. Furthermore, when assessing high-intensity situations, processing ambiguous details, or deferring to experts, they often rely heavily on social biases. It becomes almost inconsequential to listen to personal opinion if it contradicts provided information, granted the individual prioritizes authority like general expertise. These factors work in tandem with normative social influences—relying on the “importance” or “strength” of social groups, personal commitment and immediacy with said groups, and influence through size, scope, and effort. The want and need to be socially accepted is intense and observable, especially when these characteristics prioritize upholding contradicting beliefs (Fabert, 2020).
Cognitive dissonance and groupthink, while not meaning the same thing, often coincide when discussing psyche manipulation. Particularly in American politics, voters often prioritize solidarity and maintenance of the status quo in the face of adversity, regardless of its irrationality. They revere false idols, refusing to make their own decisions or finding themselves incapable of doing so. Deviating from community decisions often brings negative consequences to the contradictory individual, and so the mind becomes dissonant from self-making decisions (Aronson et. al, 2018). To be accepted into the village is to accept the village itself. Our politics have been plagued by intense cognitive dissonance, and groupthink seems to be at the very core of these extreme, growing rifts in opinion.
In Elliot Aronson and Carol Tavris’ article for The Atlantic, ‘The Role of Cognitive Dissonance in the Pandemic’ (2020), the story of the Heaven’s Gate cult is told in a foreboding manner, reporting the dangers of misguided influence and social manipulation with the power of groupthink. Through thousands of experiments and hours of manpower spent researching these events, psychologists explained psyches involved using the term cognitive dissonance. The importance of Heaven’s Gate ideologies, leadership, and concepts held intense power over the 39 members who died, and logic is sadly irrelevant to those affected by such. This article is strikingly similar to Casey Bond’s for the Huffington Post, titled "How MLMs And Cults Use The Same Mind Control Techniques” (2019). In this, Bond interviews past members of business members affected by ‘multilevel marketing companies’, or MLMs. With great detail he describes the analogous features of both cults and MLMs, in manners similar to Heaven’s gate, in which MLMs will manipulate their members with tactics like love bombing and behavioral control. We must avoid becoming cultish.
Psychologists Samuele Murtinu, Giulio Piccirilli, and Agnese Sacchi have studied how voters are affected by psychological tactics used by political parties. In their article ‘Rational inattention and politics: how parties use fiscal policies to manipulate voters’, subjects are presented with different information regarding political party. This information—consistency over time, fiscal success, or simply political association, for example—undoubtedly influenced voter decisions, allowing psychologists to analyze observable results. These results showcase multiple instances cognitive dissonance, contradictory votes made influenced by external pressures. The empirical predictions the team made were entirely from numerous advanced economies between 1999 and 2008. It is important to note that most governmental bodies in the study were observed to prioritize fiscal manipulation through provided information, and could influence voters based on how economically literate said voters were. Regardless of the level of economic literacy, most, if not all political bodies were capable of (and responsible for) manipulating voter decisions.
Another study on the topic, titled ‘Cognitive Dissonance in Groups: The Consequences of Disagreement’ by David Matz and Wendy Wood (2005), describes how cognitive dissonance theory is used to describe why people do what they do in the face of adversity, contradiction, or faulty rationale. Through an analysis of multiple studies on cognitive dissonance in groups, Matz and Wood solidify that what social priorities an individual holds will heavily influence most, if not all decision-making. Study 1 found that students experienced higher dissonance discomfort when grouped with disagreeing peers rather than agreeing ones. Study 2 confirmed that standard dissonance mitigators, such as having no choice or having an opportunity to self-affirm, similarly lessened this discomfort. In Study 3, participants resolved dissonance from group disagreement using interpersonal consensus tactics, such as persuading peers, altering their own opinions, or joining a group with like-minded individuals. Although factors like reality, logic, and consistency were often at play, these social factors were intense enough to contradict rational behaviors during the entirety of the study.
The scariest observations about these discoveries are in their relevance in American politics—news networks that lean both right and left are guilty of psychologically manipulating viewers to detrimental degrees. As a result, groupthink often holds more power than personal belief or opinion and agenda has polarized America more and more over time. Two glaring examples provided by the text provided are found in John F. Kennedy’s Bay of Pigs and George W. Bush’s War on Terror. Although groupthink heavily influenced Kennedy’s decision during the Bay of Pigs invasion, he was also torn by cognitive dissonance—caught between his personal convictions and the immediate urgency of the crisis. This failure would result in a complete restructure of his cabinet to avoid groupthink influence in the future. Just a few decades later, President Bush declared war on several Middle Eastern countries to protect his administration’s—and the American public’s—perception of terrorism. Regardless of what contradictions lie in these declarations, Bush and his cabinet fed off one another throughout his term, and both the media and citizens of the country would go on to maintain their stance on terror. To preserve their authority, political leaders actively manipulate what their electorate hears and values, yet leaders themselves are not immune; bound by both groupthink and cognitive dissonance, they often abandon rational decision-making, sacrificing individual critical thought to reinforce collective belief.
Works Cited:
Aronson, E., Wilson, T. D., & Sommers, S. R. (2018). Social Psychology (10th ed., pp. 237-238, 279-282). Pearson.
Aronson, E., & Tavris, C. (2020, July 12). The Role of Cognitive Dissonance in the Pandemic. The Atlantic.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/07/role-cognitive-dissonance-pandemic/614074/
Bond, C. (2019, August 13). How MLMs And Cults Use The Same Mind Control Techniques. Huffington Post.
Fabert, N. (2020, September 10). PSY 350: Lecture Five (Lecture). ASU.
https://canvas.asu.edu/courses/157953/pages/module-5-learning-materials?module_item_id=11128987
Matz, D. C., & Wood, W. (2005). Cognitive Dissonance in Groups: The Consequences of Disagreement.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 88(1), 22-37. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.88.1.22
Murtinu, S., Piccirilli, G. & Sacchi, A. Rational inattention and politics: how parties use fiscal policies to manipulate voters.
Public Choice. 190, 365–386 (2022). https://doi-org.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/10.1007/s11127-021-00940-8
3. The Importance of Accuracy in IAT
The Implicit Association Test, or IAT, is a method of testing that attempts to provide analytical data regarding implicit bias by using the speed at which participants associate both positive and negative feelings towards various groups (Aronson et al., 2018, p. 415). By measuring response times, researchers can evaluate the intensity of a subject’s implicit bias. However, like any experimental tool, the IAT is not foolproof and its data can be easily misinterpreted. For instance, a person might attribute their negative implicit bias toward homeless people entirely to personal upbringing, overlooking the significant influence of social media or news reporting. But, regardless of how this data is interpreted, what information the IAT provides is incredibly valuable. According to Aronson et al., “the developers of IAT, Mahzarin Banaji and Anthony Greenwald (2013), report that people are often surprised and alarmed to be told they have prejudices they are unaware of.” (2018, p. 416). To protect the integrity of these valuable insights, it is vital to control for hindsight bias and prioritize analytical accuracy.
Taking the IAT offered a surreal look into my own implicit biases as well as broader cultural tendencies. Although I was initially skeptical of the pairings—and struggled to maintain my speed in the second portion—I recognize the test's value as an analytical tool. However, it is not immune to interference. Had I known the specific categories or test words in advance, I could have intentionally altered my speed to skew the output. Ultimately, because the IAT measures reaction time, familiarity with the test structure could easily distort the data. After all, the method measures the speed at which buttons are pressed in association with groups and categories, and humans are more than capable of improving said skills in ways unassociated with the test itself.
When searching the ASU online library for peer-reviewed articles, one title caught my attention in particular due to this worry of mine: keywords being IAT and “faking”. Given the importance of recognizing implicit bias, preventing subjects from "faking" their test results is critical. Researchers Jessica Röhner, Ronald R. Holden, and Astrid Schütz (2023) investigated the extent to which participants could deliberately manipulate the IAT. In their study, participants were instructed either to fake their results unassisted or were provided specific strategies to maximize said distortions. By tracking response latency, the researchers successfully identified which manipulation strategies were used based on how much participants' speeds decreased. Ultimately, they developed indices that reliably detect faking on the IAT, enabling psychologists to minimize hindsight bias and draw more accurate, meaningful conclusions from the data.
Developing empathy, dignity, and respect for others requires an awareness of our own implicit biases. The IAT can facilitate that self-realization immediately. While the test is susceptible to misinterpretation or inaccuracy, ongoing refinements such as the diagnostic indices developed by Röhner et al., help safeguard integrity. Because methods like the IAT offer critical insights into human behavior and foster self-awareness, maintaining a healthy degree of critical scrutiny toward them is essential. Ultimately, implementing the IAT on a wider scale (while continuously auditing and refining its methodology) would yield a substantial net positive for society.
Works Cited:
Aronson, E., Wilson, T. D., & Sommers, S. R. (2018). Social Psychology (10th ed., pp. 415-416). Pearson.
Röhner, J., Holden, R.R. & Schütz, A. IAT faking indices revisited: Aspects of replicability and differential validity.
Behav Res 55, 670–693 (2023). https://doi-org.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/10.3758/s13428-022-01845-0
Thanks for reading through the work, I appreciate you greatly.
Refer to these philosophies whenever you feel like your interactions with others aren’t quite adding up—maybe your conversations conclude coldly, or your networking’s gone dry… maybe you’re just feeling a little awkward recently.
Whatever the case may be, reinforcing your social awareness is critical to your success. Especially if you’re a business owner. After all, you never know who’s watching. (Not to be creepy. It’s an integrity thing, ok?)
They might be your next best client, your next investor… your next business partner even.
First impressions, social biases, and groupthink will always be relevant in business, as business does not exist without people. It’s good to stay aware.
(People also need people to stop being so manipulative. Spread the love. Meet each other. But like, really meet each other, you know? Like, where we’re at. In-person, too. You know what I mean. Double entendres or whatever. Uh… here’s more One Piece. Episode 130, enjoy.)